Which presenters are your top and bottom 3?
- Thread starter speckledhen
- Start date
Help Support ShoppingTelly:
backstreetgirl
Registered Shopper
Top 3:
Julia - she is the most informative out of all the presenters. I turn a blind eye to her ego.
Pipa - she's fun, although sometimes she does babble on too much, but I still like her.
Kathy Tayler - seems down to earth and not up herself.
Bottom 3:
Julian - can't abide his presenting voice or the way he presents a product, I turn over whenever he's on.
Jilly - can't put my finger on why she's a least favourite, but she definitely is...and I hate the way she gives the price as 'fordy nine pounds thirdy pence.'
Alison Y - she constantly interrupts and so I find myself waiting for her to do just that, instead of enjoying the product
Julia - she is the most informative out of all the presenters. I turn a blind eye to her ego.
Pipa - she's fun, although sometimes she does babble on too much, but I still like her.
Kathy Tayler - seems down to earth and not up herself.
Bottom 3:
Julian - can't abide his presenting voice or the way he presents a product, I turn over whenever he's on.
Jilly - can't put my finger on why she's a least favourite, but she definitely is...and I hate the way she gives the price as 'fordy nine pounds thirdy pence.'
Alison Y - she constantly interrupts and so I find myself waiting for her to do just that, instead of enjoying the product
backstreetgirl
Registered Shopper
He's never been this housewive's choice, he reminds me of someone who should be in one of those huts on the beach, showing Punch & Judy. Or a magician......I find him very smarmy.
Top 3:
Kathy - doesn't come out with selling cliches
Pipa - friendly and honest
Julia - really knowledgable and I like her presenting style
Bottom 3:
The new ones - too amateurish (i've cheekily lumped them together!)
AY - voice like nails on a blackboard, always butting in, no manners, bitchy comments to guests and models
Jilly - 'jump to the phones', 'snap them up', 'I really would go for this one'
Kathy - doesn't come out with selling cliches
Pipa - friendly and honest
Julia - really knowledgable and I like her presenting style
Bottom 3:
The new ones - too amateurish (i've cheekily lumped them together!)
AY - voice like nails on a blackboard, always butting in, no manners, bitchy comments to guests and models
Jilly - 'jump to the phones', 'snap them up', 'I really would go for this one'
Pinkpussycat
Meeoow....
Top 3
- Julian - I would
- Kathy Tayler - lovely unpretentious lady
- Jill Franks - I just like her
- Miss Piggy - get over yourself luv
- Pipa - yeah yeah yeah, for me it's no no no
- Charlie - for his smarminess, praying hands and his creepy slow reveal
stratobuddy
Registered Shopper
Now we need a mathematician to analyze all the results and come up with a composite league table.
hounds-of-love
Registered Shopper
top 3
Craig
AY
Pippa
and i have to say that Debbie Flint has really grown on me, started off not liking her, but she is great now.
bottom 3
Debbie Greenwood
Jill Franks
the Irish ones, nothing to do with being Irish, everything to do with be rubbish.
Craig
AY
Pippa
and i have to say that Debbie Flint has really grown on me, started off not liking her, but she is great now.
bottom 3
Debbie Greenwood
Jill Franks
the Irish ones, nothing to do with being Irish, everything to do with be rubbish.
Frazzled
Sense of humour intact
I've tried to put them in an order of preference but my brain can't cope! - so it's just Kathy Taylor at No1
Top 3
Julia - knows her stuff - but can be too over the top!
Pipa - good fun but not when she's not in manic/shrieky mode
Alison - both the above
Bottom 3
Anna - ok ish I suppose, Don't dislike her as a person obviously but just bland
Debbie F- hard sell
Simon - tries hard but seems insincere (yes I know they all are, but it shows with him!)
Julia - knows her stuff - but can be too over the top!
Pipa - good fun but not when she's not in manic/shrieky mode
Alison - both the above
Bottom 3
Anna - ok ish I suppose, Don't dislike her as a person obviously but just bland
Debbie F- hard sell
Simon - tries hard but seems insincere (yes I know they all are, but it shows with him!)
silversequin
Registered Shopper
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2009
- Messages
- 2,041
I rate Katy Taylor, she natural and genuine
Julia R is informative and describes things well
bit stuck for a third one!!
When I am tired I switch off Claire, Alison Y and Jill F as they all stress me out and exhaust me for all the reasons mentioned by others.
Julia R is informative and describes things well
bit stuck for a third one!!
When I am tired I switch off Claire, Alison Y and Jill F as they all stress me out and exhaust me for all the reasons mentioned by others.
rainbowdottie
Registered Shopper
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2009
- Messages
- 3,531
My top 3 -
Jilly Halliday - find her a very "normal" person/mum.Can really see her fitting in at the school gates.Like her soft style presenting
Pipa - like that shes a bit "trendy" for QVC.Things she says seem to make a lot of sense IYSWIM?! again very "normal"
Craig - find the presenting style very friendly and laid back.Like that he's not afraid to put on a kipling bag,or talk about candles etc.
Bottom 3 -
Jill Franks - just so insincere.Can't bear anything about her - from the "private" jokes in the ear,to the 100 words a minute,from the gasping and wheezing breaths,to the absolute fawning over everyone and everything.
Charlie - I used to think he was OK but hes got dull and oh so repetitive.
Alison young - for the rudeness,the interrupting,the celebrity name dropping and the down right rude faces and opinions from everything to children and childbirth to sun worshipers.In jest or not.
But then I probably have an opinion on everyone - they're just "between" my top and bottom 3!!
Really like Dale - find him quite humorous.Almost very nearly made in my top 3.Wouldn't want to leave QVC.
Carmel - nice enough young girl,just doesn't come across well.Don't really think QVC is for her.
Kathy T - really want to like her,Really I do.she reminds me of a very normal mum/MIL.Just CANNOT bear the constant bumbling mistakes.Makes it very hard viewing.
Claire Sutton - in baby mode very hard to watch.Do like her when shes feeling a bit more quiet and normal.Don't like the constant fiddling and flicking of the fringe.
Julia Roberts - hard one this.I think shes QVC's best presenter.Articulate,professional,good measure of warmth and friendliness and enough about her life/kids to make it endearing without being OTT.Then I see glimpses of a real hard steely personality underneath all that.I've seen sarcastic stares,inappropriate remarks and some downright rudeness.Makes me remember that the endearing qualities I thought she had,may be thats shes just a good salesperson.
Miceal - can't understand a word he says
Ali K - absolute professional.nothing for or against really
Catherine Huntley - used to really like her.Now i just think shes losing the plot.Very insecure and it shows.However sometimes think that of julia roberts too.
Anne Dawson - no opinion really.Don't seem to see her much.
Debbie greenwood - almost in my top 3 also - just wasn't enough room lol.Find her very quick witted and humorous
debbie flint - hated her first time round.didn't want her to come back.couldn't bear to watch.stuck with her once as I wanted to watch the birkenstock show and she was very informative.Watch her a lot now -and find her very good and honest about sizing.Not too keen on the hard sales and hate the laugh but can get over it
Anna - boring.bad hair,makeup and clothes.Not in the right job
Simon - boring.very grey.
Julian - love him,another one who would have gone into my top 3 if there was room.honest and likeable.wish he did more hours.
phew!
Jilly Halliday - find her a very "normal" person/mum.Can really see her fitting in at the school gates.Like her soft style presenting
Pipa - like that shes a bit "trendy" for QVC.Things she says seem to make a lot of sense IYSWIM?! again very "normal"
Craig - find the presenting style very friendly and laid back.Like that he's not afraid to put on a kipling bag,or talk about candles etc.
Bottom 3 -
Jill Franks - just so insincere.Can't bear anything about her - from the "private" jokes in the ear,to the 100 words a minute,from the gasping and wheezing breaths,to the absolute fawning over everyone and everything.
Charlie - I used to think he was OK but hes got dull and oh so repetitive.
Alison young - for the rudeness,the interrupting,the celebrity name dropping and the down right rude faces and opinions from everything to children and childbirth to sun worshipers.In jest or not.
But then I probably have an opinion on everyone - they're just "between" my top and bottom 3!!
Really like Dale - find him quite humorous.Almost very nearly made in my top 3.Wouldn't want to leave QVC.
Carmel - nice enough young girl,just doesn't come across well.Don't really think QVC is for her.
Kathy T - really want to like her,Really I do.she reminds me of a very normal mum/MIL.Just CANNOT bear the constant bumbling mistakes.Makes it very hard viewing.
Claire Sutton - in baby mode very hard to watch.Do like her when shes feeling a bit more quiet and normal.Don't like the constant fiddling and flicking of the fringe.
Julia Roberts - hard one this.I think shes QVC's best presenter.Articulate,professional,good measure of warmth and friendliness and enough about her life/kids to make it endearing without being OTT.Then I see glimpses of a real hard steely personality underneath all that.I've seen sarcastic stares,inappropriate remarks and some downright rudeness.Makes me remember that the endearing qualities I thought she had,may be thats shes just a good salesperson.
Miceal - can't understand a word he says
Ali K - absolute professional.nothing for or against really
Catherine Huntley - used to really like her.Now i just think shes losing the plot.Very insecure and it shows.However sometimes think that of julia roberts too.
Anne Dawson - no opinion really.Don't seem to see her much.
Debbie greenwood - almost in my top 3 also - just wasn't enough room lol.Find her very quick witted and humorous
debbie flint - hated her first time round.didn't want her to come back.couldn't bear to watch.stuck with her once as I wanted to watch the birkenstock show and she was very informative.Watch her a lot now -and find her very good and honest about sizing.Not too keen on the hard sales and hate the laugh but can get over it
Anna - boring.bad hair,makeup and clothes.Not in the right job
Simon - boring.very grey.
Julian - love him,another one who would have gone into my top 3 if there was room.honest and likeable.wish he did more hours.
phew!
Loveinamist
Registered Shopper
This is a very difficult thread for me, I need a minute................
AllThatGlitters
Registered Shopper
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2009
- Messages
- 739
Top: Pipa, Debbie G., Kathy T.
Bottom: Anna (definitely not in the right job, regards us all as old farts), Ali Young (no manners), Jill Franks (it's all about memememememememe).
Bottom: Anna (definitely not in the right job, regards us all as old farts), Ali Young (no manners), Jill Franks (it's all about memememememememe).
Top 3
Debbie flint. Seems down to earth and good fun
Julia Roberts. Most informative
Alison Keenan. Professional and easy to watch
Bottom 3
Jill franks goes on too much about what she's had bought /bought herself rather than what she's meant to be selling
Charlie brooks soooooo boring needs new batteries
Claire Sutton the voice
Debbie flint. Seems down to earth and good fun
Julia Roberts. Most informative
Alison Keenan. Professional and easy to watch
Bottom 3
Jill franks goes on too much about what she's had bought /bought herself rather than what she's meant to be selling
Charlie brooks soooooo boring needs new batteries
Claire Sutton the voice
Rentochops
AKA Slinkychops
Julian, Debbie G, Charlie
Bottom Claire, Pipa, Flinty
Bottom Claire, Pipa, Flinty
top three: alison young. wicked sense of humour and very funny to watch. julia robersts. very informative and professional. likes to wind up the forumers methinks. dale because i think he seems to really enjoy working for qvc and is quite nice to watch.
the bottom for me tbh are the newer presenters because i am a creature of habit and like most of the older presenters who have been there years.
the bottom for me tbh are the newer presenters because i am a creature of habit and like most of the older presenters who have been there years.
